May 2018 Game of the Month: Quackshot Starring Donald Duck

[meleu]

@jwbmonk you're probably using an incompatible ROM.

Check the OP on the RetroAchievements forum topic for this game: http://retroachievements.org/viewtopic.php?t=41

[mediamogul]

@jwbmonk

I had the same issue. This was also the first ROM I've noticed to be incompatible for me as well.

[meleu]

@mediamogul we did a massive clean up on the last couple of months. We had so many cheated ROMs linked to games. I mean patched ROMs changed to have infinite lives/money/ammo/whatever...

We also unlinked many ROMs where the RAM doesn't behave like in the ROM used by the achievement developer.

Also, there's a big chance that many actually compatible ROMs were unlinked in this process. But if you guys are pretty sure it was working before, you can post the checksum of your existing ROM in the forum topic of the respective game and also the exact name you have for it and a developer will review it with you to see if it is compatible. Reporting on our discord server gives more visibility for this request. https://discordapp.com/invite/TdfC3r7

[mediamogul]

@meleu said in May Game of the Month: Quackshot Starring Donald Duck:

But if you guys are pretty sure it was working before, you can post the checksum

It might be a good idea to see if @jwbmonk and I are using the same ROM. I'll post the checksum of mine here a bit later today.

[mediamogul]

Ok, my CRC32 Checksum is a5c946b3.

This is for the (UE) ROM dump. Judging by the forum link above, only the (W) ROM dumps are currently compatible.

[meleu]

@mediamogul Yeah, your ROM is incompatible...

We recommend achievement developers to choose NTSC USA release ROMs if available, because 60 FPS is a smoother gaming experience. PAL European releases run at 50 FPS, and are to be avoided in most cases. NTSC Japan releases also run at 60 FPS , but is only the best choice if the game was a Japan-exclusive release. Needing to resort to a PAL European release game should be a last resort case (Europe-only exclusive), and is typically a very select few unique games from the entire console's library.

[mediamogul]

@meleu

Isn't (UE) the same ROM classification as (W) depending of whether or not you're using 'Good' or 'TOSEC' releases? I had read in the past that these particular titles adjust their timing based on region detection.

[cyperghost]

@mediamogul This is very interesting ;) ROM Suffix Explanations
For sure (W) should be (JUE) ;)

[mediamogul]

@cyperghost

So, I guess the final question would be, are (UE) and (JUE) viable for the RetroAchievements, seeing as how they, alongside (U) and (W) are all NTSC compliant?

[mediamogul]

@meleu, @cyperghost

I believe I figured it out. The full name of the 'Good' dump in question is:

QuackShot Starring Donald Duck (UE) ~ QuackShot - I Love Donald Duck - Guruzia Ou no Hihou (J) (v1.1)

After studying up on the 'Good' naming conventions, the (UE) is meant to denote the English title that precedes it, whereas (J) denotes it's Japanese name. So, it looks like this ROM is in fact a (JUE), making it the same as (W) in TOSEC. I guess there were never any other regional versions of 'Quackshot' released other than this one. I'll make a report to the discord server when I have some time.

[meleu]

@mediamogul you can also give me the md5 and I link it to our database. And then you can test it to see if it'll work. There's an easy cheevo for this test: getting 5 peppers in Duckburg.

[obsidianspider]

I don't go for retro achievements, but I really enjoyed this game. I played it on my Genesis and while a bit confusing at parts, I had a lot of fun. Did anyone else think it was a bit odd that the powerup to give you full health was a cooked duck? (Ok, maybe a chicken or turkey, but still.)

[hooperre]

@obsidianspider said in May Game of the Month: Quackshot Starring Donald Duck:

I don't go for retro achievements, but I really enjoyed this game. I played it on my Genesis and while a bit confusing at parts, I had a lot of fun. Did anyone else think it was a bit odd that the powerup to give you full health was a cooked duck? (Ok, maybe a chicken or turkey, but still.)

Glad to hear you enjoyed it. Sometimes it's hard to separate 'good' from 'nostalgic' haha.

[lilbud]

So I'll start a running list of who is eligible for voting for June GOTM

Me
@meleu
@obsidianspider
@mediamogul

[mediamogul]

@lilbud

You can add me to the list as well. Although it wasn't my particular jam, I figured why not finish what I started. In an overall good looking game, I thought the Transylvania level was especially gorgeous. I always love how Disney handles the macabre, going all the way back to 'The Skeleton Dance', or my own personal favorite Disney short, 'The Mad Doctor'. I also ended up liking how the acquisition of items was handled for progression. Doubling back to locations to use them helped break the action up in a nice way and made the game have more of a globetrotting feel.

[mediamogul]

I just remembered that 'The Mad Doctor' is one of three Disney cartoons that accidentally entered into the public domain, so I can't help but post it here.

[obsidianspider]

@hooperre No nostalgia for me as I never had a Sega as a kid.

[obsidianspider]

@lilbud My suggestion for June: Riviera - The Promised Land - Game Boy Advance

[lilbud]

@obsidianspider So its like a Final Fantasy Tactics type of game? Or closer to Fire Emblem?

The Promised Land

[obsidianspider]

@lilbud I've never played either of those so I'm not sure how to answer your question. It's an RPG.