mame2003-plus: hundreds of new games, improved input, features, new bugs - now with runahead support
-
@janderclander14 are there any libretro cores that currently work with rgb commander?
edit: I've looked over the site and the answer appears to be "no." The source is closed although the author pledges to open the next version.
The earliest version of mainline MAME that the author has tried is 0.169:
Linux : 0.? <-> 0.169 - Auto detection works fine. Rom dependant blinking LEDs are functional through old communication system.
I don't know for sure but I think that even the "old communication system" is one generation after the code we have from MAME 0.78. If that's the case, it maybe RGB Commander could be made to interface with RetroArch's LED driver eventually assuming that MAME 2003-Plus is able to send data to RA. It would require the participation of the RGB author at that point.
-
MAME hooker (http://dragonking.arcadecontrols.com/static.php?page=aboutmamehooker) seems like a more likely initial target for this due to maturity, open source, and API than RGB Commander. Again this is purely speculative and would require someone to add support for MAME 2003-Plus to that tool if and when LED signaling is working within the core.
All that is to say that this is a little closer to being possible than I first guessed.
-
@markwkidd Thanks for having a look at it. The only thing I can add is that the author of RGBcommander has been quite reactive to requests via email and, so far, is the only software that works on retropie (Mamehooker is Windows only).
-
it isint a problem writing to the pi io in theroy ra has a driver for it. I checked mame thedata is coming through form the drivers that support it. We just need to decide what we want to do with it.
et_led_status num:0 status:0
set_led_status num:1 status:0
set_led_status num:0 status:0
set_led_status num:1 status:0
set_led_status num:0 status:0
set_led_status num:1 status:0
set_led_status num:0 status:4
set_led_status num:1 status:0
led display updated
set_led_status num:0 status:4
set_led_status num:1 status:0
set_led_status num:0 status:0
set_led_status num:1 status:0
led display updated
set_led_status num:0 status:0
set_led_status num:1 status:0
set_led_status num:0 status:0
set_led_status num:1 status:2
led display updated
set_led_status num:0 status:0
set_led_status num:1 status:0
led display updated
set_led_status num:0 status:0
set_led_status num:1 status:2
led display updated
set_led_status num:0 status:0
set_led_status num:1 status:0
led display updated
set_led_status num:0 status:0
set_led_status num:1 status:2
led display updated
set_led_status num:0 status:0
set_led_status num:1 status:0
led display updated
set_led_status num:0 status:0
set_led_status num:1 status:2
led display updated
set_led_status num:0 status:0
set_led_status num:1 status:0
led display updated
set_led_status num:0 status:0
set_led_status num:1 status:2
led display updated
set_led_status num:0 status:0
set_led_status num:1 status:0
led display updatedect
The problem is we need a system wide solution for RA.Writing to the pie gpio ports is very doable by the looks of things what system will you be using?
-
@grant2258 I think it would be better to mimic the general behavior of the mame outputs as in the standard Mame, so that other apps more focused on managing leds/outputs (such as Rgbcommander) can use these outputs. Otherwise lr-mame will be cluttered with led-related options.
In fact, led management usually requires dedicated hardware (such as Ledwiz), due to the Pi's gpio is too limited in the number of leds that can be managed and the current it supports. Rgbcommader supports most of such hardware already so there is no need for Mame to do that, other than provide the outputs.
-
I really dont agree here windows users dont have that option and i have no idea what you mean why you say mimic mame078 just send pulses to numlock and caplock ect
-
here is the windows code for mame078 you want us to flash the numlock keys?
-
@grant2258 Sorry if I wasn't clear. Windows users already employ Mamehooker instead of Rgbcommander to catch Mame outputs and drive leds, counters, etc. Both Windows and linux standard Mames already provide these outputs (and the non-Retroarch linux version provides outputs on the Pi, which can be catched by Rgbcommander, but runs too slow).
The request was whether the Mame output system (as implemented in the standard Mame until version 169) could be ported to the Retroarch core. The link to the Rgbcommander site I included above explains a little how the outputs work through the different Mame versions.
-
ok do me a favor test mame standard 078 see if it hooks the output from what i see in the standard code youll get 3 leds only in mame078
-
@grant2258 I had a look at it and it seems the standard Mame 0.78 doesn't implement the output system, just the keyboard leds. According to Aaron Giles, the output system was introduced in version 107u4 (August 2006). The following link explains how the outputs work.
https://aarongiles.com/old/?p=181
It seems that the ouput system seamlessly redirects keyboard leds and backdrop lights, which have been supported in much earlier versions of Mame, so that third party softwares can use them to light external leds. Obviouly, more complex outputs (like force feedback effects in racing games) are only available in versions after 2006 and newer drivers. The following posts by the developer of Mamehooker provide some info on this:
http://forum.arcadecontrols.com/index.php/topic,100880.msg1066814.html#msg1066814
forum.arcadecontrols.com/index.php/topic,101789.0/all.html
I don't know whether it could be feasible to backport the mame output system from v107u4 to lr-mame so that at least keyboard leds and backdrop lights are offered as outputs. More complex outputs would likely be unfeasible, because they would imply backporting much newer (and less efficient) drivers.
-
backdrop leds already work and the flashing numlock ect is easy enough to add back. To me a flashing numlock and capslock doesnt mean a lot. I there any reason you want random numnlock ect flashing?i would probably vary from game to game but it wouldnt be a big deal to add outputs that arent there to a drivers in some cases. I just dont see how a random blinking led tells you anything.
RA has a led driver for raspberry pi io and and overlay. you just want random things to blink ?
-
im guess what im trying to say is what function do you personally want these led functions to do for you.
If i had some kind of idea of what the end result would do for you and why that would go a long way into understanding what you want to do. Is it just lighting up joystick buttons or something else?
Ra can do things already with the outputs if they are there like in outrun if you crash you could make the joypad rumble to emulate the steering wheel shaking ect. Im sure we can work something out if its to lightup joystick leds
-
@grant2258 Assuming buttons have leds, a basic use would be to blink the start button after inserting a coin or the coin button when no credits have been inserted. In specific games, leds can have specific meanings (as in the original cabinet) such as the braking light in Outrun or the police lights in Chase hq. These can be mapped to unused buttons or to leds in the cabinet marquee. The thing is that these outputs are already there for many mame drivers and led management can be handled by programs such as Rgbcommander (for linux) or Mamehooker (for Windows). What these programs need is to hook to the Mame outputs in other to know when the leds should be lightened when the game runs. Because this infraestructure relies on the standard Mame output protocol, if this protocol can be reproduced in lr-mame, then they will work without having to adapt drivers or to introduce specific code in lr-mame to manage leds. If not, then I think developing an ad hoc system that lights keyboard leds or outputs the gpio will be of no interest, because it is not standard and output management programs will not work.
-
the game would have to support this do you have an example of a game that does this ? so i can see the naming conventions used. makehooker isint using mame communications by the looks of things it uses dde.
I see you pointing out examples which is helpful but i need a specific game and example that you do use so i can look at the source of teh game and makehooker. It would give me a clearer picture of whats going on.
let me be more specfic teh outputs would need customized per game it isint hard to make code to send to a raspberry pi io ports to blink a led driver ect there is no need for mamehooker in that sense. we need something that works on linux and windows dde is windows ill try take a look at what rgbcommander is
-
from the info i have looked up rgbcommander lights up the buttons / leds based on romname via an xml file.
http://forum.arcadecontrols.com/index.php/topic,154590.0.html
-
@grant2258 In the following posts you can find some examples of games that have outputs:
Outrun:
forum.arcadecontrols.com/index.php/topic,101789.0/all.html
Ajax:
http://forum.arcadecontrols.com/index.php/topic,82987.msg866938.html#msg866938
Spyhunter:
http://forum.arcadecontrols.com/index.php/topic,82987.msg866958.html#msg866958
Dig dug, q-bert:
http://forum.arcadecontrols.com/index.php/topic,151464.msg1583332.html#msg1583332
Moreover, many games should send outputs to blink the start/coin buttons.
Personally, I use RGBcommander with Retropie (other led management softwares like Mame hooker or LedBlindky are Windows only), and employ a led driver to light up leds (Ledwiz), because the Pi gpio is too limited for this. Indeed, RGBcommander lights the buttons used by the games/system by using an config Xml file and the name of the game and emulator/core. Also, it can also read some basic mame outputs, such as start, coin and a pair or in-game leds and make this leds blink when needed. See the Mame section of its homepage:
users.telenet.be/rgbcommander/
Obviously, the latter only works with the standard Mame.
-
I just need one game that blinks the start and coin buttons for you then i can start piecing something together on how the information is sent. from what i can see the xml is setting the lights so i need a game that behaves like this for you to start to see whats going on here.
-
@grant2258 You can use classic games such as: Galaxian, Dig Dug, Galaga or Asteroids. For these, the start button blinks when you insert some credits. This is the behavior of the original cabinets and it is properly emulated by Mame via outputs.
-
@janderclander14 is this working on your setup right now is what im asking. We can control leds very easily on the pi with a driver like here
-
the only reason im asking this is because every video ive seen is a random led flashing that we can do easily
Contributions to the project are always appreciated, so if you would like to support us with a donation you can do so here.
Hosting provided by Mythic-Beasts. See the Hosting Information page for more information.