Why separate Neo Geo system from Arcade?

barbudreadmon

@Cook1e_mr said in Why separate Neo Geo system from Arcade?:

I go to retroarch menu within the dipswitch i still see the full BIOS's AES Japan, AES Asia etc

That's perfectly normal, dipswitches are hardcoded and don't care about the file actually present in your neogeo.zip

@Cook1e_mr said in Why separate Neo Geo system from Arcade?:

My logic was to place a neogeo.zip with only neo-epo.bin

Don't do that, there are other required files in neogeo.zip, i suggest removing only neo-po.bin instead.

@Cook1e_mr said in Why separate Neo Geo system from Arcade?:

Is there a way of finding where the BIOS is being sourced from?

The bios/parent are sourced from rom folder, then BIOS/fbneo folder, then BIOS folder, it'll stop after finding one romset by the right name, meaning if a neogeo.zip is present in your rom folder it won't even look at the other folders, even if the first neogeo.zip found is missing files.

Clyde

@barbudreadmon said in Why separate Neo Geo system from Arcade?:

The bios/parent are sourced from rom folder, then BIOS/fbneo folder, then BIOS folder, it'll stop after finding one romset by the right name, meaning if a neogeo.zip is present in your rom folder it won't even look at the other folders, even if the first neogeo.zip found is missing files.

Is it the same with integrated bios files when built by Clrmamepro with the option "Separate BIOS Sets" unchecked? (I suspect so.)

Just curious, as I recently built a new FBNeo set in this form.

barbudreadmon

@Clyde said in Why separate Neo Geo system from Arcade?:

Is it the same with integrated bios files when built by Clrmamepro with the option "Separate BIOS Sets" unchecked

Yes, it won't even look at neogeo.zip if it can find the bios files in the game romset

Cook1e_mr

@barbudreadmon said in Why separate Neo Geo system from Arcade?:

Don't do that, there are other required files in neogeo.zip, i suggest removing only neo-po.bin instead.

I did this originally but the emulator was still loading in Japanese. I therefore think something else is at play. so i was trying to rule out as many variables as i possibly could.

@Clyde said in Why separate Neo Geo system from Arcade?:

Yes, it won't even look at neogeo.zip if it can find the bios files in the game romset

hadn't considered that, will have to check my archives

Cook1e_mr

@Cook1e_mr said in Why separate Neo Geo system from Arcade?:

@Clyde said in Why separate Neo Geo system from Arcade?:

Yes, it won't even look at neogeo.zip if it can find the bios files in the game romset

hadn't considered that, will have to check my archives

OK checked and this is my problem, the BIOS is within the ROM archive, need to work out how to remove that easily now.

thanks for the help

Clyde

@Cook1e_mr said in Why separate Neo Geo system from Arcade?:

OK checked and this is my problem, the BIOS is within the ROM archive, need to work out how to remove that easily now.

Remove the bios from the game roms? One relatively easy way is to rebuild the romset as "non-merged" with Clrmame and the option "Separate BIOS Sets" turned ON in the scanner and the rebuilder.

CapNinja

@thelostsoul after using this tutorial for a few months, the comment from our fellow above made me think about games in japanese. I was just accepting that with suspension of belief and now I'm trying to put in english, but I'm having this problem:
If I change to "Dipswitch below"and then "AES ASIA", automatically all roms will change to MVS.
If I do the changes one by one, my choice will be maintained. But I don't want to open every single game for this.
Help, please.

thelostsoul

@CapNinja My reply may be disappointing, so sorry to say that. Above we discussed this issue and we couldn't find a solution. Changing to "Dipswitch" means, that the setting from the individual cabinet (Dipswitches) will be used. Then you can have individual settings for each single game, but off course this is not what we want.

Currently it seems to be a limitation by the emulator settings not to be able to set the specific BIOS version system wide.

CargoRunner

Just wanted to thank you for this fantastic and comprehensive piece of work. It is EXACTLY what I want to do and you have done all the hard work and research to put this together. Thank you so much for sharing your work

thelostsoul

@cargorunner What a nice reply, hehe. Just a little disclaimer, as someone pointed it out in the replies here. There is a thing I could not solve and maybe a reason not to do all this stuff here. Apparently the games are all in Japanese then, not the US version, because RetroArch/RetroPie lack the ability to specify this thing. The last replies in this thread talk about this "issue".

To change the BIOS to English, you have to change emulator setting to "Use BIOS specified in BIOS dipswitch below". The problem is, the dipswitch setting is per game and you would need to set it for each individual game and save the settings for each game separately. That is not what I want to do, therefore the games stay in Japanese version.

Also have in mind this tutorial is for an older version of the emulator and RetroPie and Raspberry Pi 3. I just want to bring this to your attention. Always do a backup before following the instructions. And have fun tinkering. :-)

philcsf

Been setting this up the past few days, cheers from the advice.

I already knew about "core_options_path" after some long google searching the other month, but wish it was advertised more on the RetroPie docs. Useful for many things, such as turning on BLARGG filters for some platforms (SMS, GEN) but not for others (GG) while using the same emulator.

I have all my BIOS files merged into the individual ZIPs rather than using an external neogeo.zip. All I needed to do was force that folder's core options to "AES Mode", then delete neo-po.bin (Japanese AES BIOS) from each ZIP in that folder. If it's missing, FBNeo falls back to neo-epo.bin (Asia/English AES BIOS) automatically.

I can even re-add neo-po.bin to certain ZIP files by preference, such as getting blood in the Metal Slug games.

thelostsoul

@philcsf Great to know its working! Deleting the Japanese BIOS withing the files would be my last resort, as there is no other way to accomplish the goal within the emulator settings.

luckyluca

I'm using fb-neo, and had my core-options set to fbneo-neogeo-mode = "DIPSWITCH"
It appears as if it behaves like MVS, but for safety, I'm thinking of changing it to MVS for the arcade.

When making a copy of the core options to neogeo-core-options.cfg and changing to AES as suggested, should I also copy and add all fbneo core lines (there are plenty including lots of per-game dipswitches, one for each game executed)?

Also, would it be problematic using a rom not ending with h in AES neogeo mode?

Thanks

thelostsoul

@luckyluca said in Why separate Neo Geo system from Arcade?:

When making a copy of the core options to neogeo-core-options.cfg and changing to AES as suggested, should I also copy and add all fbneo core lines (there are plenty including lots of per-game dipswitches, one for each game executed)?

It's been a while when configuring it, I had just copied the entire file and made it act like an independent emulator. I actually don't know if RetroPie or fbneo will look for in "/opt/retropie/configs/fba/" first, if you load up a game from Neo Geo systems folder. If that is the case, then you can only include the differences you want to have in "/opt/retropie/configs/neogeo/neogeo-core-options.cfg" . If RetroPie requires you to have two different files, then you are probably out of luck.
Or you can try to use the "include" statement on top of the neogeo-core-options.cfg to point to the file from fba. But I don't know if this works.

As a sidenote, when looking through my old Raspberry Pi 3 installation backups, I don't see any neogeo-core-options.cfg files anymore, but retroarch-core-options.cfg. Not sure if the tutorial is outdated. Sorry for the late reply and I hope you get it working.

Also, would it be problematic using a rom not ending with h in AES neogeo mode?

Not at all. This was just my personal decision to use these specific versions of the ROMs. Although I couldn't spot any differences tbh