Fullscreen is always on when starting an arcade game

[rogeriol]

I have a rasp4 with RetroPie and fbneo. No matter the configuration files on root RetroPie or arcade disabling Fullscreen (and leaving fullscreen window on), when starting the game Fullscreen is always enabled, leaving the game smaller on TV (4k Samsung).
This is undesirable because the ratio works better on fullscr window , so I have to manually disable fullscreen every time in Retroarch config vídeo.
Any tip to disable the Fullscreen on arcade that works? Cuz disabling in the config files does nothing (setting Fullscreen to false)

Thanks

[mitu]

Please fill out the info requested in https://retropie.org.uk/forum/topic/3/read-this-first.

[rogeriol]

@mitu

sure, there it goes.

Pi Model or other hardware: (B, B+, 2 B, 3, X86 PC etc..)
Pi 4

Power Supply used: (If using a Pi)
generic 3A, no power issues

RetroPie Version Used (eg 3.6, 3.8.1, 4.1 - do not write latest):
4.8.4

Built From: (Pre made SD Image on RetroPie website, Berryboot, or on top of existing OS etc.. - please provide the filename of any image used)
retropie-buster-4.8-rpi4_400.img

USB Devices connected:
none

Controller used:
8bitdo FC30 BT

Error messages received:
none, fullscreen always enabled on start

File: (File with issue - with FULL path)
Emulator: (Name of emulator - if applicable)
FBNeo

Attachment of config files:
links below

How to replicate the problem:
start an arcade game, fullscreen is always ON. No way to start it OFF.

retroarch cfg

arcade fbneo cfg

tia

[mitu]

Since you have modified the stock arcade system config, my guess is you modified some of the video aspect/scale options and this produces scaling you're noticing.

Remove the retroarch.cfg from your arcade config folder and then re-install lr-fbneo to re-generate it. See if you get the same scaling issue.

[rogeriol]

@mitu it's not the case, but I did what you suggested.

The same continues, I cannot start an arcade game in window fulscreen only, fullscreen is also enabled every time.

To illustrate:

fs enabled (always)

fs game (more borders up and down)

fs disabled (manual, window fs enabled)

window fs game (up and down borders smaller, best fit)

thanks

[mitu]

Hm, the screenshot you posted doesn't look like the stock RetroArch RGUI config - are you sure you've reset the configuration ? Get a verbose log and post it on pastebin.com.

[ByteThis]

@rogeriol I'm sure I saw your post on Reddit about this problem and you said you were not using the Retropie stock image but a 3rd party one. If so.that may be your problem.

[rogeriol]

@ByteThis hi, I did not post this anywhere else. I'm using the stock image, latest.

I found out this problem happens in several cores, if not all. NES, SNES, PSX, MSX.

Have deleted retroarch config and reinstalled it. Changed the config again to:

# Start in fullscreen. Can be changed at runtime.
video_fullscreen = "false"

I just cannot disable fulscreen mode with the config, only manually inside retroarch.

[barbudreadmon]

@rogeriol I'm not sure i understand what you are trying to do here. You are running retroarch outside of a desktop environment, so it will always run fullscreen since there is no window manager to run it in windowed mode.
By "fullscreen", are you maybe refering to wrong aspect ratio and/or integer scaling ?

[rogeriol]

@mitu here is the log

verbose

with this, I figure the culprit is the --appendconfig /dev/shm/retroarch.cfg.

This file content (below) sets fulscreen true and it's recreated every time, so no point in editing it. I havent found how this is created or how to disable the -appendconfig when running retroarch... any tips?

video_refresh_rate = "60"
video_fullscreen = "true"
video_fullscreen_x = "1280"
video_fullscreen_y = "720"
libretro_directory = "/opt/retropie/libretrocores/lr-fceumm"

TIA

[rogeriol]

@barbudreadmon should work only window fullscreen, this is what I want, so the game will fit better on the screen.

Works manually, I dont see why retroarch cannot start with fullscreen disabled and window fs enabled.

[mitu]

@rogeriol said in Fullscreen is always on when starting an arcade game:

with this, I figure the culprit is the --appendconfig /dev/shm/retroarch.cfg.

This file content (below) sets fulscreen true and it's recreated every time, so no point in editing it. I havent found how this is created or how to disable the -appendconfig when running retroarch... any tips?

/dev/shm/retroarch.cfg contains the resolution that you chose from the runcommand launch menu to be applied to the core/game. You should check the launch menu to see what resolution you have set there.

[barbudreadmon]

@rogeriol said in Fullscreen is always on when starting an arcade game:

so the game will fit better on the screen.

This is the part i don't understand as a developer on this project: switching between fullscreen and windowed fullscreen is not supposed to be used to change how a game "fit" on the screen. Looks to me like you are using some kind of weird bug to get around something that you are supposed to handle through integer scaling and/or aspect ratio.

To clarify, if windowed fullscreen acts differently from fullscreen as far as how games "fit" on the screen, then this is definitely a retroarch bug and not something intended, it might even be already fixed in the latest version of retroarch (which isn't available on retropie yet ?) since it does sound strangely similar to the issue i fixed in https://github.com/libretro/RetroArch/pull/15247 a few months ago.

Nonetheless, if you absolutely want your windowed fullscreen thingy, you might need to set video_windowed_fullscreen in retroarch.cfg.

[rogeriol]

@mitu runcommand launch menu has nothing set on in besides the emulator to use with all games of the same category.

It's fetching this from somewhere else. I have set the resolutions on the main config.cfg but
video_fullscreen = "false"
is not respected, somehow it gets transformed into
video_fullscreen = "true" in this appendconfig file.

@barbudreadmon I agree, my tv even resyncs when disabling fulscreen manually, but since retroarch cryptic configurations and the high probability to mess things up when changing a lot of configs, I thought it would be easier to just disable fulscreeen at launch, but it's proving to be a challenge as well.
video_windowed_fullscreen is set to true since the beginning.

sds

[mitu]

@rogeriol said in Fullscreen is always on when starting an arcade game:

It's fetching this from somewhere else. I have set the resolutions on the main config.cfg but
video_fullscreen = "false"
is not respected, somehow it gets transformed into
video_fullscreen = "true" in this appendconfig file.

The fullscreen is automatically added by Runcommand, based on your detected resolution. As @barbudreadmon said, since emulators are running 'headless' on the Pi, there's no windowing system present so the emulator window is always 'fullscreen'.

Did you modify the config.txt file on the boot partition of your sdcard to force 720p as the video resolution ?

[rogeriol]

@mitu I changed resolution on raspi config to 1280 720 to be easier on the rendering, but no mention to Fullscreen here.

1280 720 was having an effect on my TV upscale so that borders were huge. Still don't understand why window fs made things better.

As a workaround I changed it to 1920 1080 on raspi config so Fullscreen takes the whole area now. Still the setting can't be changed, but the main problem is solved.

If I leave the resolution adjust to best fit the tv, 4k is selected and I believe this could tax the rendering on performance in RetroArch.

Thanks

[mitu]

@rogeriol said in Fullscreen is always on when starting an arcade game:

Still the setting can't be changed, but the main problem is solved.

You can still change the rendering resolution from the Runcommand launch menu, overriding the default one. 1080p is a good compromise though - 4k is a bit much for the GPU rendering.

[dankcushions]

@rogeriol said in Fullscreen is always on when starting an arcade game:

If I leave the resolution adjust to best fit the tv, 4k is selected and I believe this could tax the rendering on performance in RetroArch.

https://retropie.org.uk/docs/Pi4/#4k-video-display

@rogeriol said in Fullscreen is always on when starting an arcade game:

I changed resolution on raspi config to 1280 720 to be easier on the rendering

pi4 is very capable of doing 1080p so i would use that, using the method in the previous link.