Where to (legally) acquire content to play on RetroPie

markwkidd

@hooperre said in Where to (legally) acquire content to play on RetroPie:

Certainly seems like it would cover ROMs for systems embedded in RetroPie, but it's so poorly defined who really knows? Seems strange that, if given an exemption from DMCA, that the Internet Archive would take it and run with it and distribute things without consent from Congress and a clear understanding of their exemption. Seems like someone getting out of jail and going to the bank next door and robbing it. Hard part was already done! Also, having that exemption would likely mean that Congress is well aware of their comings and goings and that there have likely been no complaints filed against them as they would likely be sensitive to any complaints they received. Again, like @dankcushions said, we're all left just grasping at straws though.

Thanks! This sounds exactly like the exception that the Internet Archive worked on.

If this topic seems interesting to other people I'll dig up links to the original filings.

While there are ample primary sources about the archive.org DMCA exception there is little informed discussion of it online that I have ever found online.

Maybe that should be another thread, but -- without posting any links to ROMs of course -- I'd be glad to talk about it.

I've been informally approached to put together a presentation on intellectual property and emulation for game development conferences. At this point I'm not planning to do so, but this is a topic that has a lot of cultural significance as well as technology significance. Maybe someone else should put together a presentation! :)

Anyway, if someone starts that thread, I'll gladly join in.

mediamogul

On the subject of the games themselves, I downloaded and played 'Ultimate PONG', 'Donkey Kong Arcade' and 'Yogi's Frustration'. 'Ultimate PONG' is very straight-forward and a PONG package that's hard to beat. I thought I'd miss the analog control found in Atari's own 'Video Olympics'/'PONG Sports', but it feels like everything was tailored to the digital controls for this and it plays very smoothly as a result.

'Donkey Kong Arcade' is very impressive. We've all heard the rumors that Coleco intentionally sabotaged their own version of 'Donkey Kong' for the Intellivision in an effort to sell more Colecovisions. I've never been fully convinced of that, but this version does prove that they certainly didn't give it their all, regardless of their motives. 'Donkey Kong Arcade' looks and plays beautifully and captures the one quality you should look for in any DK port, the inability to put it down.

'Yogi's Frustration' apparently started off it's life as a loose adaptation of the Charlie Chaplin film 'Modern Times', one of the first films to have synchronized sound. It's a great commentary on the dehumanizing effect technology can have on mankind, yet still manages to be one of his funniest films. The fact that the Tramp says absolutely nothing in his first "talkie" alone makes me laugh. 'Yogi's Frustration' would have been the second video game adaptation of a silent movie, alongside Activision's 'Keystone Kapers' which was based on the short film series, 'Keystone Cops'. Mattel decided to attach Yogi and Booboo to sell more copies and after the game tested poorly, it was discovered that while the game play itself was well received, it was actually Yogi and Booboo who were testing poorly. This particular game is so unique, I feel like I need more time with it than what I was able to spend today. However, I can say that I do enjoy playing it and that already passes a base-level requirement that all too many games haven't.

xFlesk

i think this is a right thread ;)
here you have a great free new game for NES (english and polish language)

http://www.mteegfx.com/grunio

cheers

SgtJimmyRustles

@mediamogul

Do you have a link to images showing "Donky Kong Arcade"?

mediamogul

@sgtjimmyrustles

Yessir. Pictures and a comparison video trailer can be found here, along with the ROM.

SgtJimmyRustles

@mediamogul

Yeah, that's much better than what was released.

Appreciate the link.

rpieguy

@sgtjimmyrustles Here's an updated version of Intellivision DK Arcade, also posted earlier in this thread. It has both Japanese and North American modes of the game and bug fixes. http://www.carlmuellerjr.com/2016/12/d1k-arcade-rom-download-page-dk-arcade.html

kikinaak

The dreamcast has a homebrew dev scene that is still active to this day. There's several games that can be had for free legally. Unfortunately a lot of the sites that host only the homebrew have gone down, and the only one I can find thats still up also hosts commercial games. so I cant post the link. But I found them pretty quick via google.

markwkidd

@kikinaak said in Where to (legally) acquire content to play on RetroPie:

The dreamcast has a homebrew dev scene that is still active to this day. There's several games that can be had for free legally. Unfortunately a lot of the sites that host only the homebrew have gone down, and the only one I can find thats still up also hosts commercial games. so I cant post the link. But I found them pretty quick via google.

You can try the internet archive wayback machine and search for those old Dreamcast sites. It often, but not always, archives download links in addition to web pages.

Another thing to do is go to a page like the one with the updated DK Arcade. Then tell the Wayback Machine to manually archive it as it is today. Then tell the archive to manually archive the ROM download. That way DK Arcade has a good change of remaining available even after this site goes down.

SgtJimmyRustles

Heads up, I found the Sega Genesis bundle back for $10.

https://www.fanatical.com/en/bundle/sega-megadrive-and-genesis-classics-bundle?utm_source=Fanatical+Newsletter&utm_campaign=2e552441c8-SEGAd_03_16_2018&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_3437eaaeba-2e552441c8-431067757&mc_cid=2e552441c8&mc_eid=a56592a707

hooperre

@sgtjimmyrustles Thanks! Got it.

SgtJimmyRustles

@hooperre

No problem!

hooperre

I'm gonna shotgun this out to everyone for feedback. I don't want to start my own thread, but at the same time don't want to hijack this thread.

I'm a business owner in the States and would like to provide my patrons with a throwback arcade style system to play with until I'm ready for them. I have acquired a bunch of ROMs from places like Steam and freeware ROMs so I assume it would be 'legal' for me to have them on a system as long as I'm not collecting money from it for plays or anything? Just thought it would be fun to share my love for games and nostalgia with patrons. I think it will be a hit.

markwkidd

@hooperre said in Where to (legally) acquire content to play on RetroPie:

I'm gonna shotgun this out to everyone for feedback. I don't want to start my own thread, but at the same time don't want to hijack this thread.

I'm a business owner in the States and would like to provide my patrons with a throwback arcade style system to play with until I'm ready for them. I have acquired a bunch of ROMs from places like Steam and freeware ROMs so I assume it would be 'legal' for me to have them on a system as long as I'm not collecting money from it for plays or anything? Just thought it would be fun to share my love for games and nostalgia with patrons. I think it will be a hit.

Edit: more thorough answers below.

herb_fargus

@hooperre none of us are lawyers, so in order to get a definitive answer in your country you'd have to speak with a lawyer there.

I had a dentist that had a RoboCop cab on Freeplay, and another one that had an Xbox. Where the legality of it all lies idk, same idea as showing movies, the technicalilty may deem it illegal but is rarely enforced for such small venues

dankcushions

@hooperre said in Where to (legally) acquire content to play on RetroPie:

I'm gonna shotgun this out to everyone for feedback. I don't want to start my own thread, but at the same time don't want to hijack this thread.

I'm a business owner in the States and would like to provide my patrons with a throwback arcade style system to play with until I'm ready for them. I have acquired a bunch of ROMs from places like Steam and freeware ROMs so I assume it would be 'legal' for me to have them on a system as long as I'm not collecting money from it for plays or anything? Just thought it would be fun to share my love for games and nostalgia with patrons. I think it will be a hit.

i think technically it's illegal: https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2013/07/why-nintendo-can-legally-shut-down-any-smash-bros-tournament-it-wants/

mediamogul

@hooperre

Many people ask a similar question, looking to find whether they're in the right or wrong. What most don't consider is that even if you're in the right, anything can be taken to court if an offended party feels otherwise. In those cases, the winner is usually whoever has the deeper pockets. Having purchased the games legitimately really only affords you a defense should it ever go to court, in which case it would need to be examined whether or not the license covers public use, or if it's transferable to other methods of playback. That being said, legal action would be a worse case scenario and a cease and desist order would likely come as an initial response to which you could simply abide and hopefully be done with it. Personally, I would adhere to the age-old advice of "Don't start nothin', won't be nothin'".

hooperre

@mediamogul @dankcushions @herb_fargus Thanks for responding and I am, as always, grateful for your efforts and hard work. I'm certainly not trying to skirt any legal grounds here as it's not worth harming my business, but I assumed as long as I'm not making money off of it legally purchased games would be a fair go. Back in the day I had an orthodontist with Donkey Kong Country on SNES. My girlfriend is actually a lawyer here, and said she would do the legal research. She's not into gaming whatsoever, so I'd have to push for it. Maybe there will be a time in which I'll ask her to do it.

Now back on topic. Ha.

Clyde

@hooperre said in Where to (legally) acquire content to play on RetroPie:

I assumed as long as I'm not making money off of it legally purchased games would be a fair go.

Some of the problems with that are that you only acquired a license for private use by yourself, and that the copyright holders could argue that they lose income if people play games freely at your place instead of buying them.

Fruitybit

It’s a shame ppl and prs can’t make this easier. We have both (soon to become one) at work, so can play any other media pretty much. It would make sense (but only if it were the kind of thing likely to be enforced- who checks what games you’re playing at work!? (Other than my boss of course;))