The Ideal RetroPie

lilbud

I'd also like to be able to pull in more than one image per game. Imagine if a game could have a big fan-art background, box art, a slideshow of screenshots and gameplay gif. You can use the Universal XML Scraper to fudge this, but it takes some set up time and it's a lot more work than a lot of people want to do.

Something like this? https://material-design.storage.googleapis.com/publish/tv_v_2/tvexternal/0B56kA3exHMkQQ0gtN2w2cGxZWUE/app_structure_detail_01.jpg

mrbwa1

It;'s hard to make suggestions because I don't have the knowledge to do them and don't like telling the devs what to do since they put in so much hard work already. But here it goes:

Config Auto-Backup/reversion - Automatically backup the previous config file and have one of those "Press a Key withing 30 seconds to accept" prompts. That way if you nuke a config, it'll auto-revert back to the last known state. Of course this would be separate from manually editing config files for those who like to go that route.

mediamogul

RetroPie is not too far off from my ideal emulation setup to begin with. The absolute most important issue for me is how the games perform and control. To that end, I'd want to see an increase of RAM, as well as a more capable GPU for the Pi and a universal control mapping system that is not only versatile, but user-friendly as well.

drake999

@herb_fargus I agree with pretty much all the points you made here. Really the biggest thing for me is a better GPU, whilst still retaining a power requirement no more than 2.5A. But considering the prevalence of relatively powerful GPU's in mobile phones and tablets this shouldn't be too hard to accomplish, however I know the Raspberry Pi foundation wants to stick to open architectures so this no doubt restricts the options significantly. Also I'm essentially just reiterating something I read, but I understand that despite the CPU now being 64-bit capable, the GPU is still a 32-bit architecture. It would be nice to have a 64-bit GPU to go with the new CPU architecture. I wonder if there is a new Broadcom VideoCore V on the horizon or something. As it stands right now, CPU heavy emulators usually work great on the Pi3 CPU, but despite the modest overclocking achievable with the GPU, GPU heavy emulation suffers in HD resolutions (I insist on HD resolution so if something doesn't work well, I omit it rather than opting for lower resolution).

Also an increase in RAM and being able to easily define which controller is first player and which is second player would also be nice. I pretty much like the front end the way it is, but having a web GUI for monitoring and management would be awesome. Right now I just used SSH for monitoring temperatures, CPU, and memory usage. I'm not terribly concerned about internal flash memory myself, unless it will achieve speeds significantly higher than the approximate average 40 MB/s I've achieved with my 128 GB card.

Also metadata like box art and game description for ROM's would greatly enhance the frontend, but other than that the frontend is fine as is in my opinion.

Ranma

To be honest I find it amazing as it is. Maybe it's my age but I know if I'd seen this when I was younger it would have blown my mind. I think it was version 4.0.2 when I started to think "hang on, this is now doing what I imagined it would do", and feels now complete.

I'd like to see N64 emulation improved but I think everyone wants that no matter what machine you are running . I'm not convinced throwing more power at that would make much difference; certainly not at the moment anyway. Otherwise this is an amazing feat as it stands and I'm not sure at any point I've thought that it needs to do more. :)

mattrixk

Kind of like that @lilbud, also like this and this (the images are too big for this post and I'm too lazy to shrink them and upload them to Imgur).

PetroRie

I would like to see a Raspberry which can run GameCube emulation. Now I still have to use my modded Wii to play them but who knows whats going to be in the future. As for RetroPie, it's kinda fine how it is now. So far all the games I played ran fine! I can play all the games i used to play as a kid on the SNES, N64, PSX, Genesis never owned a Neo Geo console but Neo Geo games are extremely fun to play as well as MAME roms. I started to play them because of my older brother who used to go to arcade halls back in the early 90ties.

But you know what would make RetroPie freaking awesome? If it had a great multiplayer support, like you can add friends, chat with them, talk to them via your mic, invite them to play games with you. And watching your friends play remotely and they can give you control over their controller so you can play remotely. Kinda like the PS4. That would be AWESOME!

lilbud

I would like to see a Raspberry which can run GameCube emulation.

Probably by the PI 6, if ever. My mid-2015 computer can barely play GC games.

monkee

Frontend:
Attract-Mode is a very fine addition! Beautiful UI with Marquees, Videos, Categories, Tags, Favorites and much more.

It is already available in experimental packages - needs some integrating, but looks far better than EmulationStation - in my opinion.
http://attractmode.org/

Just my 3 cents

Thanks for all your work! It is a pleasure to play with retropie.

lilbud

@herb_fargus Here goes your hope for more ram http://www.techrepublic.com/article/raspberry-pi-in-2017-new-boards-new-oses-and-more/

mrbwa1

@lilbud No ram, but the Model A 3 could be kinda cool for retropie builds using bluetooth controllers.

backstander

@mrbwa1

No ram, but the Model A 3 could be kinda cool for retropie builds using bluetooth controllers.

It will also be great for those retro handheld builds! @obsidianspider needs to read that!

obsidianspider

@backstander I need to finish one project first, but I can see a 3-powered handheld in the future.

FlyingTomahawk

Hardware: A pi yet to be released with a minimum of 2 GB of RAM, perhaps some flash memory and of course all the current options of the pi 3. Better GPU.

Enough power to be able to run Naomi/Atomiswave games that would be wicked. I wouldn't mind a small cooling fan if necessary.

The Front End: I was envisioning something like open emu where you have a list of systems on the left and a grid view of sorts of the games on the right, and possible video and music support if I were feeling ambitious.

A better filtering system would be nice. If you have a couple roms its OK but if you start to exceed 100 roms per emulator it would be nice to have the possibilities to sort/filter by genre, A-Z, Z-A, most played evtl. add a favorites feature to add a star next to the roms and only display those. I have seen someone posting a video once with such extended features.

Controls: I was thinking of there being a diagram for each system of that systems controller as you configured your controller so you could know exactly what your buttons corresponded to on the original controller. Also to be able to have settings to control which controller is which player.

I think once you know how the controller setup stuff works its easy but a diagram like you have in windows under advanced settings would be not a bad idea. That would make jstest obsolete.
If I remember right there was a controller sorting feature inside the RetroPie right? Like put port 0 on second position and port 1 on first, something like that.

Save States/Load States: When you save it takes a screenshot at your current position in the game and then when you go to load it opens up a menu where you can choose from your savestate slots like the old point and click games or the nes classic

I never used that feature yet. Most games have a build in saving feature. But I have seen that people request that a lot, the screenshot thing. Kinda like the classic NES has?

Web Dashboard: A dashboard that shows all of the pi's settings: temp, space left, up time, etc. Along with a file transfer section that checks hashes of your roms so you know if they work or not before you even try them

That would be VERY helpful.

I guess I am looking forward to a RPi6? or 7? with some of the mentioned improvements? Not sure how much influence RetroPie can have on them though. EmulationStation? Retroarch? Raspberry?

barbudreadmon

Considering your hardware requests, you guys should probably take a look at udoo x86. It is pricier than a rpi, but still a good deal.

FlyingTomahawk

@barbudreadmon

Nice! That's really nice! Thx.
Wonder what specs are needed to run Naomi/Atomiswave.

barbudreadmon

@FlyingTomahawk said in The Ideal RetroPie:

Wonder what specs are needed to run Naomi/Atomiswave.

From what i know, demul is more demanding than pcsx2/dolphin, and i expect mame to be even more demanding to play Naomi/Atomiswave, so don't expect too much from a computer with a cpu below 3Ghz.

My main goals with my udoo x86 will be to play bomberman (saturn), guardian heroes (saturn), chuchu rocket (dreamcast) and towerfall ascension (x86), which i can't on my rpi.

FlyingTomahawk

@barbudreadmon said in The Ideal RetroPie:

3Ghz.. man that would be a lot for such a small PCB. Guess I stick with my PC for the time being, at least for Naomi/Atomiswave.

bomberman (saturn)

THAT is an awesome game, and probably the best Bomberman from all systems. I have the original on Saturn and I own the Bomberman multi tap for it.
If I'm not mistaken that is the only Bomberman that you can play 2 player story mode.

obsidianspider

It's hard to reimagine something when you've been immersed in it for a long time, but one thing that I think would make RetroPie better for me would be another/better way to manage game metadata (gamelist.xml and snapshots). A web UI would be great, but I'm not sure how much overhead a webserver would add to things.

barbudreadmon

@FlyingTomahawk said in The Ideal RetroPie:

I have the original on Saturn and I own the Bomerman multi tap for it.

Same with 2 multitap, but my saturn is dead and i don't feel like buying a new one : having something more compact, more durable with wireless controllers seems better.