FBA vs. MAME

markwkidd

@grant2258 Maybe I'll give 2003+ a shot. I remember that Rush'n Attack / Green Beret didn't work properly in Mame2003. When the game would boot it was just bringing up a volume slider on the screen. Similar to Spy Hunter and Rampage.

That is all fixed now in mame2003-plus. Eventually the fixes may go back to mame2003

Loggahead

@markwkidd said in FBA vs. MAME:

@loggahead said in FBA vs. MAME:

@grant2258 Maybe I'll give 2003+ a shot. I remember that Rush'n Attack / Green Beret didn't work properly in Mame2003. When the game would boot it was just bringing up a volume slider on the screen. Similar to Spy Hunter and Rampage.

That is all fixed now in mame2003-plus. Eventually the fixes may go back to mame2003

Excellent! So I noticed that mame2003+ is an experimental package, should I only look to use this on roms I can't get to run in mame2003 or is it safe to consider using + as a replacement to mame2003?

markwkidd

mame2003-plus is still in testing, but it's getting fairly polished at this point IMO. arcadez has been working on it for almost a year, and a few other of us have put in weeks to months.

It works better than mame2003 most of the time, and has more than 150 more working games, but every once in a while we have a regression or other new bug.

You seem to be very thorough in your approach to arcade emulation -- you would be very welcome as a user/tester. Games that haven't ever worked right in mame2003 are getting fixed, and new ones added.

Loggahead

@markwkidd This all sounds awesome! I will install the package tonight and start testing roms.

Is it ok to do from binary or do I need to do it from source? Where is the best place to report any issues I find?

barbudreadmon

@loggahead Well, i'm not extremely happy with the current fix, but Rush'n Attack / Green Beret are working properly in fba with the latest commits.

grant2258

@barbudreadmon said in FBA vs. MAME:

@loggahead Well, i'm not extremely happy with the current fix, but Rush'n Attack / Green Beret are working properly in fba with the latest commits.

we had this problem on mame2003+ we did a different work around for mame2003 as well a general soultion for this would be to set the sample rate timing to to something sensible that can handle the 30fps ie 60.fps and 48k sample means the lowest framerate you can achive is 48 fps if fps is below sample rate change sample rate timing in the core

barbudreadmon

@grant2258 Thanks for the explanation

Loggahead

@markwkidd said in FBA vs. MAME:

mame2003-plus is still in testing, but it's getting fairly polished at this point IMO. arcadez has been working on it for almost a year, and a few other of us have put in weeks to months.

It works better than mame2003 most of the time, and has more than 150 more working games, but every once in a while we have a regression or other new bug.

You seem to be very thorough in your approach to arcade emulation -- you would be very welcome as a user/tester. Games that haven't ever worked right in mame2003 are getting fixed, and new ones added.

Every time I try and install lr-mame2003-plus under experimental packages it eventually comes back with an error saying that it "Could not successfully build lr-mame2003-plus. I've tried multiple times and keep getting that same message. Any thoughts?

markwkidd

@loggahead said in FBA vs. MAME:

@markwkidd said in FBA vs. MAME:

mame2003-plus is still in testing, but it's getting fairly polished at this point IMO. arcadez has been working on it for almost a year, and a few other of us have put in weeks to months.

It works better than mame2003 most of the time, and has more than 150 more working games, but every once in a while we have a regression or other new bug.

You seem to be very thorough in your approach to arcade emulation -- you would be very welcome as a user/tester. Games that haven't ever worked right in mame2003 are getting fixed, and new ones added.

Every time I try and install lr-mame2003-plus under experimental packages it eventually comes back with an error saying that it "Could not successfully build lr-mame2003-plus. I've tried multiple times and keep getting that same message. Any thoughts?

Could you update RetroPie-Setup and then try to build mame2003-plus again? The build script that is part of RetroPie-Setup was updated a week or so ago.

Loggahead

@markwkidd That's probably it. Will try that now.

Loggahead

Got a question on Golden Axe II (ga2.zip). It doesn't appear to be available for fba so I've been running it in mame2003. Mame says that video emulation isn't 100% correct and the main thing I notice is that the shadows are all messed up. Is there a better emulator for Golden Axe II?

markwkidd

@loggahead said in FBA vs. MAME:

Got a question on Golden Axe II (ga2.zip). It doesn't appear to be available for fba so I've been running it in mame2003. Mame says that video emulation isn't 100% correct and the main thing I notice is that the shadows are all messed up. What's the best emulator option for Golden Axe II?

I don't see anything in the history of the Golden Axe II driver to explain for the glitch you're seeing in mame2003, but sometimes those records are incomplete.

If you can confirm the shadow issue in mame2003-plus you would be welcome to file an Issue report. It may be fixable.

Loggahead

@markwkidd How do I file an issue report? I have a couple issues I found.

Also, I can't seem to pull up the Tab menu in mame2003+. Is there a different hotkey for the mame menu? I need to change some per game controls in there.

markwkidd

@loggahead said in FBA vs. MAME:

@markwkidd How do I file an issue report? I have a couple issues I found.

Also, I can't seem to pull up the Tab menu in mame2003+. Is there a different hotkey for the mame menu? I need to change some per game controls in there.

Great!

You can file issues in the github repository: https://github.com/libretro/mame2003-plus-libretro

There is also a new forum thread: https://retropie.org.uk/forum/topic/17766/mame2003-plus-250-new-games-new-input-system-new-features-new-bugs

mame2003-plus's default input mode is retropad -- you can get into the MAME menu in retropad mode by pressing Select + X and toggling MAME Menu in the core options.

You can also change your input mode to mame_keyboard to switch to a traditional all-keyboard mode where the Tab will launch the MAME Menu.

finally, you can set the core option to simultaneous mode which will read inputs form the keyboard and from the retropad simultaneously, as in "classic" mame2003.

Loggahead

@markwkidd Ah! Very cool! I'll play around with the Mame menu inside the retropad menu and see if I can do what I need to do there. Very cool! If I have to do the all-keyboard mode, will that mess with my controller mappings at all? I basically keep a keyboard behind my cabinet's coin door that I use when needed but my IPAC2 is programmed as 2 separate controllers instead of keyboard keys.

I'll get a couple of the issue submitted. Thanks for all of the help! I like where this 2003+ is going!

markwkidd

@loggahead said in FBA vs. MAME:

@markwkidd Ah! Very cool! I'll play around with the Mame menu inside the retropad menu and see if I can do what I need to do there. Very cool! If I have to do the all-keyboard mode, will that mess with my controller mappings at all? I basically keep a keyboard behind my cabinet's coin door that I use when needed but my IPAC2 is programmed as 2 separate controllers instead of keyboard keys.

I'll get a couple of the issue submitted. Thanks for all of the help! I like where this 2003+ is going!

Nice, thanks!

The concept is that if you are using a retropad (including a keyboard or arcade controls seen that are set up as a retropad!) that you should be able to do anything you need to configure mame2003 without using the mame_keyboard at all.

mame_keyboard is really oriented towards people who have controls and other aspects of their configuration that are based around the legacy MAME keyboard interface. As the retropad mode improves, even those folks might be able to switch to retropad, but for the forseable future the mame_keyboard mode will be there so they can keep the workflow they're used to.

Do I understand right that you're saying you only use the keyboard for configuration? I'd appreciate it greatly if you could let me know if there are parts of your configuration you still can't reach without the mame_keyboard input being active.

Loggahead

@markwkidd said in FBA vs. MAME:

you still can't reach without th

That is correct on the mame_keyboard. I ONLY use it if absolutely neccessary and that typically only happens when I need to modify a specific game's controls that isn't possible in the Quick Menu. For example, I needed to map Robotron on my cabinet to use my P2 joystick as the "P1 Right Joystick".

I'll start using the retropad menu and see if I come across any limitations.

grant2258

anyone else finding robocop is running bad on fba on retropie?

Darksavior

@grant2258 I thought the opposite. Though the intro music does start a second later and not immediately like in mame2003, at least fba has sound effects for insert coin, when you obtain a gun, and probably other sound effects missing from mame2003. Also, I noticed mame2003 (I'm using plus) is a bit brighter than fba. I don't know which one has the correct brightness but I'll go with fba.

In terms of performance? I wouldn't know. My pi3b+'s at 1.5ghz.

FBA

Mame2003-plus

grant2258

@darksavior said in FBA vs. MAME:

ss

dont mean sound just performance you can adjust the brightness in 2003+