SD card issues

StuMcBill

Ok,

I have fully formatted my cards (which show as compatible on the compatibility website) but I still get errors with them.

Can anyone recommend somewhere I can get a 32gb card in the UK which you have experience with. I've had a look at the compatibility site, but most of them I find are very slightly different model numbers to those listed- so would like some personal experience if possible?

Cheers
Stewart

edmaul69

@stumcbill where did you buy the cards? On Ebay people sell mostly all bootleg fake micro sd cards that arent even the size it is supposed to be. Once you put so much on them they start having issues.

StuMcBill

@edmaul69 said in SD card issues:

@stumcbill where did you buy the cards? On Ebay people sell mostly all bootleg fake micro sd cards that arent even the size it is supposed to be. Once you put so much on them they start having issues.

I've always bought my cards from mymemory.co.uk or amazon, so I'm pretty sure they are not fakes.

I've just seen a 32gb sandisk in Tesco which is a SDSQUNC-032G-GN6IA, but the compatibility site lists SDSQUNC-064G-GN6IA as not compatible, so I'm not sure about getting one, although the 32gb one is sdhc and the 64 is sdxc so maybe that makes a difference?

ortsac

@stumcbill Some questions:

What kind of SD card reader/writer are you using? SD card reader/writers are tailored for high capacity SD and others looks like they are working but when the card is read back elsewhere, it fails.
Which operating system are you using it on? Windows, Apple OS, Android, Linux, etc?
Which application are you using to format the card?
What type of formatting? NTFS, FAT32, etc? Retropie is good with FAT32, not with NTFS. I have Windows 10 and use SDFormatter and set to FAT32. Operating system and application tend to format the media to their particular defaults. Check your settings.
What program are you using to write the image on the card? I use Win32DiskImager and works wonders for me.

You could have a good compatible SD card but any of these could be setting you up for failure. Or simply your SD card is dud.

edmaul69

@stumcbill that compatibility list is not anything i would go by at all. It is old, outdated and has no way of being kept up to date. And just because one person had an issue with a card doesnt make it incompatible. And i got a 128gb samsung evo micro sd card from amazon that was fake. It wasnt even 16gb worth of data before it started corrupting the card.

StuMcBill

@ortsac said in SD card issues:

@stumcbill Some questions:

What kind of SD card reader/writer are you using? SD card reader/writers are tailored for high capacity SD and others looks like they are working but when the card is read back elsewhere, it fails.

Which operating system are you using it on? Windows, Apple OS, Android, Linux, etc?

Which application are you using to format the card?

What type of formatting? NTFS, FAT32, etc? Retropie is good with FAT32, not with NTFS. I have Windows 10 and use SDFormatter and set to FAT32. Operating system and application tend to format the media to their particular defaults. Check your settings.

What program are you using to write the image on the card? I use Win32DiskImager and works wonders for me.

You could have a good compatible SD card but any of these could be setting you up for failure. Or simply your SD card is dud.

It’s a combined port replicator designed for my MacBook Pro (usb c)
Mac OS
SDFormatter for Mac
FAT32
ApplePi-Baker

I might try doing it through windows and see how I get on!

ByteThis

I only own sandisk cards..tried others..all crap and no luck.Bought only from local electronic stores..nothing online.

edmaul69

@bytethis i only buy local big box stores due to bootlegs. I only buy samsung evo's now. Better than sandisks. Never had a single disk card corruption on 3 pi's and i kill the power all the time while testing.

ByteThis

@edmaul69 I have read many forums with peeps having good luck with samsungs, and bad luck...had a samsung..was junk..tossed it in the garbage. Everyone's personal tastes I guess.Glad they work great for you!

edmaul69

@bytethis the biggest problem is samsungs are the best and they are faked soo much more than any others. I actually had gotten a 128gb bootleg version off of amazon. I am willing to pay the local price to guarantee its legit. Sucks you had a bad card.