Mapping a keypress to a joystick (Fuse/others)

SpudsMcToole

@mediamogul Ha, I forgot to include my standard "please don't mention the absolutely terrifying xboxdrv" disclaimer :D

mediamogul

Understandable. I might be confusing you with someone else I've spoken to in the past, but I thought I remembered you being pretty proficient with it. The learning curve can indeed be pretty steep.

SpudsMcToole

@mediamogul No, that definitely wasn't me :D

SpudsMcToole

@spudsmctoole So I guess from the lack of answers (and going by similar previous threads), this is a thing that basically just can't be done. What a weird thing to omit in a platform as endlessly configurable as Retropie/Retroarch - you'd think mapping controls to buttons would be the first thing anyone would ever want to do. Oh well, thanks for the replies anyway.

spud11

@spudsmctoole @mediamogul It was me, I reckon!

SpudsMcToole

@spud11 What? We look NOTHING alike! :D

mediamogul

@spud11 said in Mapping a keypress to a joystick (Fuse/others):

It was me, I reckon!

Hey, there you are! I was about to chalk you up to a hallucination, or the Mandela effect. I'm working on solving a few big things with xboxdrv right now. First, is allowing control of the Runcommand menu on launch, which only needs a little more testing. Second is much bigger and involves getting the exec mapping command to work in xboxdrv when executed as root.

This would open the door for a million use cases, as it could launch any bash script from a button command. Two examples off hand are universal screen shot capabilities using Raspi2PNG and the ability change your entire controller mapping on the fly with a simple button press or combo. The latter could be put to great use for changing a joystick from digital to analog on the fly, or 8-way direction to 4-way restricted. In effect, one map that called two others could be used universally throughout the entire MAME library. Keen stuff.

mediamogul

@spudsmctoole said in Mapping a keypress to a joystick (Fuse/others):

you'd think mapping controls to buttons would be the first thing anyone would ever want to do.

When I was setting up RetroPie for the first time, this was exactly the problem I ran into over and over. I had six other emulation rigs on various platforms prior to this and was used to a level of control over input that I wasn't finding in RetroPie as a whole. This is not the fault of the RetroPie project itself mind you. It's simply a side-effect of having the option to run so many different software solutions in one package. Rather than throw my hands up and admit defeat, I sought out external mapping solutions, which ultimately led me to xboxdrv.

Since there were no guides available at the time, it took me THREE MONTHS of on and off experimenting to come up with a work flow that would mesh with RetroPie. I've heard you mention several times about being "terrified" at learning various control schemes, but I think you're expecting that you should understand it all immediately and that can indeed be terrifying. Why not start small and just work on this one issue as you have time. The success and failures you have will in-turn give you the knowledge to solve other issues that might arise.

So I guess from the lack of answers... this is a thing that basically just can't be done.

@dudleydes gave you a software alternative for ZX Spectrum emulation that has mapping capabilities and I offered a solution that can be used universally. However, both might depend on exactly what kind of joystick you're using. If you could post the model, it might help.

spud11

@mediamogul That would be very useful. My runcommand-onstart file is now 113Kb in size, but I've found it has to be devoted purely to xboxdrv and case $2. If I try to add anything else to it with more general application like trying to invoke a bash script unrelated to xboxdrv, runcommand-onstart just doesn't work.

Also, because I'm using $2, it's got to the point where I've found myself regularly having to copy binaries like advmame, rename them to something else like "cocktail" (for vertical/cocktail oriented games) and then create a whole new xboxdrv command in runcommand-onstart just to cater for those roms.

It would be handy to have a bit more flexibility in runcommand-onstart indeed.

mediamogul

@spud11 said in Mapping a keypress to a joystick (Fuse/others):

My runcommand-onstart file is now 113Kb in size, but I've found it has to be devoted purely to xboxdrv and case $2. If I try to add anything else to it with more general application like trying to invoke a bash script unrelated to xboxdrv, runcommand-onstart just doesn't work.

I run 26 systems that make use of xboxdrv, sometimes having several dozen exceptions made for individual games. I've managed to keep the size of my runcommand-onstart.sh down to 39.9k by offloading the execution of xboxdrv itself to separate scripts. All the if/then stuff is still there, but once the conditions are met, it launches an outside script with the xboxdrv command. That may help to alleviate your situation.