Open Joystick Talk
-
@Clyde Replying here so as not to tread up that other thread. Good review of those mag stiks. So do you like them? I have two of them as well, and I never warmed up to them, mostly because of the clicky switches. Add that to your cons. I can't seem to live without leaf. I went with wico 8 ways with no restriction. I think I got them from Groovy. I have a vertical cab with two 8-ways (yes plenty of vertical 8 way shmups) and a 4-way, and I half way wish I had just a vertical with a 4 way. I want to build a Galaga reproduction, something that looks and feels a bit more dedicated. I think we agree that the aircraft carrier is no joy.
Whats your collection like? I've seen you on the forums quite a bit along with Caver (who is a big help).
I try and build reproductions, each with its own control scheme. I'm up to 5 with 2 more to go.
ws
-
@wstanek I sold the mag stik's and went back to my j-stick's. I just couldn't get used to them, they also didn't seem to make contact to the switches all the time making for some frustrating play. Was a great idea to have it switchable from the top, but if they don't work all the time then they are useless.
Some day I'll do the the servo stik on these, just no room in the current cabinet.
-
@wstanek Even after 1½ years, I like my Mag-Stiks very much. The relatively noisy switches don't bother me much, and as I wrote before, they are more silent than those of the Sanwa JLF-TP-8YT-SK. In fact, I like to hear that my moves are recognized. Curiously, it's the other way around with buttons – I loathe clicky ones, all of the 16 buttons on my cab don't have microswitches for that reason.
However, I've added this to my OP with a notice that they are not soldered and thus, can be replaced with more silent ones (contrary to some Sanwa sticks who have soldered switches 👎 ). Thanks for the feedback.
As for my „collection“, I only have the one cab, my apartment just doesn't have the space for more. That said, I'd love to have one or two specialized cabs for trackball, flightstick+spinner, and/or driving games. The one original cab I would take extreme measures to make room for is TRON. 😋
In addition to my upright cabinet, I have Retropie installations on my mini pc and my Laptop that I keep sync'ed with the Linux tool Unison. The mini pc is connected to my video projector. I don't want to brag, but it's a special kind of experience to play the old games with a picture of approx. 3x2.25 meters. 😎
@stoney66 It's sad to hear that the Mag-Stiks didn't do it for you, but everyone has different preferences. As I wrote in my OP, my first problems were gone after I reassembled the stick properly. Over the time since the beginning of 2018, one of them aquired a slight weakness in recognizing the "right" direction in 4-way-mode. I plan to remove it from the cab for more a more thorough diagnosis. Apart from that, both still work perfectly including the 4/8-switching.
-
@Clyde I'm gonna give those sticks another try! I didn't hate them, and honestly, I never gave them enough play time. I will read up on the tweaks.
Big screen sounds awesome. Blast the sound as well?
I'm right in the middle of building a Mad Planets- trigger stick and spinner. I could have done a Tron, but my reproduction would never do that cab justice. Can't wait to play Tron, DOT, Mad Planets, and whatever else that control scheme is good for. Gorf I guess, Satans hollow.
I have limited space as well, I build slim cabs that are only about 18" deep, fixed to the wall. You should build panels for your PC. Pedestal?
I buy old panels off ebay and build the cabs. I picked up a tempest panel and a pole position panel. Get that Alan-1 yoke!
-
@wstanek I think they deserve a second chance to earn your favour. If they don't, at least you'll be sure about that.
I myself consider buying one or two Sanwa JLW-UM-8, which I mentioned earlier in this thread, for some other controller project or as replacements in my two Mayflash Arcade Fight Sticks (V2 and F300). Besides, I have to buy some stuff at ArcadeWorld UK before the Brexit kicks in and Britain couldn't be toll-free for the rest of Europe anymore. 😉
Of course my mini pc is also connected to my stereo, since it also serves as a home cinema system. 🍿
So, you're buying the panels and build the rest of the cab "around" them? Are there any photos online? I would really like to see them. 😊
-
@Clyde Yes I posted something last year, and I see that you commented on it! Thank you. https://retropie.org.uk/forum/topic/18433/tempest-cab-joins-the-arcade
I'm always on the lookout for the right joysticks. I buy from GroovyGameGear.
Any experience with their products? They sell something called a Leaf Pro for $20, I have those and like them, but then they have something called a Dominux8 which is $50 and supposed to be premium. Im interested to know how much better it could be. I've also bought several items from Ultimarc--great products.I'm starting my Mad Planets build this weekend, keep an eye out for posts.
Regards,
Warren -
@wstanek Ah yes, haha. I didn't remember that that was you. As I said there already, great gaming room!
Alas, GGG is in the USA and thus, not really practical for me here in Europe. I began a test order of a single joystick and the shipping rates ranged from $27.25 to $69.70 depending on the shipping method selected. That said, I'll have to wait how expensive ordering from the UK might get if the Hard Brexit really comes (doesn't look good so far). Since there are no really good arcade shops here in Germany, maybe oversee orders won't make such a difference. 😉 😞
I wish you fun and success with your new project!
-
Have you considered the Servostik? I am going back and forth between the Magstik Plus and the ServoStik. I believe that the Servostik uses the Sanwa JLW and automatically switches between 4 and 8.
-
No, I haven't. Although it would be cool to change the restrictor automatically, the magnets of the Mag-Stik trumped that for me. Also, the more complex tech in the Servostik increases the chances of hardware failure. Finally, I don't know if there's a Linux driver for it, but that's only the last straw besides the other reasons.
-
this is getting released for the Switch in the west in January. i want it! should work great with retropie? Screenshot_20191006_235210.jpg
-
-
@Clyde i would assume its pretty much a switch pro controller in a fancy casing, and I believe those work out of the box on Retropie.
-
-
@thelostsoul Oh, didnt think of that. Just have to wait and see I guess.
Ill pick one up if the price isnt outrageous when it hits Europe.*Edit, saw the price now, 60 Pounds. Thats less than the pro controller where Im at atleast.
-
@Dipkid Why not use one of the myriads of USB wheels? Is it the Mario design or what makes this wheel so appealing to you?
-
@Clyde haha, I just like video-gamey stuff. That it looks like a mcdonalds toy is a big plus. Also It matches my 2001 Coca Cola LG tv..
-
@thelostsoul said in Open Joystick Talk:
@Dipkid @Clyde I am not entirely sure here. The pedals are most likely analogue-buttons, but the switch controller don't have analogue shoulder buttons or any other. That was always a problem for Switch racing games. So, maybe it is not just the same gamepad driver.
The pedals could be mapped to the two axes of the second analog stick. But being that it's designed for Mario Kart, analog pedals would be unnecessary.
-
@Thorr69 Either Nintendo goes the lazy way or they have addressed the issue with missing analog buttons for racing games. And I don't believe that this is just made for Mario Kart, but possible. I was just bringing this idea up, because this could solve the problem for other racing games. If that is the case, then my guess is that a new gamepad could come out too. Off course just WILD WILD speculation on my side.
-
@lukabrazi the servo stik is the sanwa JLW just has the side car servo included. I bought just the servo by itself to install on a JLW. I was able to get the servo working in both windows and linux (from katie snow) as well as just using a switch on the top of the CP (this requires flashing the servo though and it will never work with software after that!).
Contributions to the project are always appreciated, so if you would like to support us with a donation you can do so here.
Hosting provided by Mythic-Beasts. See the Hosting Information page for more information.