Controller config - no longer working

mitu

It looks like the settings for ignoring the 'Motion Sensors' did not work. I'll test it myself with a DS4.
In your configuration file, there's a missing entry for the 1st controller ([Input-SDL-Control1]), you either didn't paste it or it's not present. When you're trying out the 2nd player in Mupen64plus, do you also have the other controllers (SNES Innext) plugged in ? Did you try with just the BT controllers connected to see if the 2nd player appears ?

MisterMints

@mitu said in Controller config - no longer working:

It looks like the settings for ignoring the 'Motion Sensors' did not work. I'll test it myself with a DS4.
In your configuration file, there's a missing entry for the 1st controller ([Input-SDL-Control1]), you either didn't paste it or it's not present.

[Input-SDL-Control1] is in the mupen64plus.cfg file, I must have just not copied it across.

When you're trying out the 2nd player in Mupen64plus, do you also have the other controllers (SNES Innext) plugged in ? Did you try with just the BT controllers connected to see if the 2nd player appears ?

I have done it with the USB controls connected and unconnected. No difference.

mitu

OK, so I connected a DS4 and - as expected - the systems sees both the Motion Sensors and the Wireless Controller as gamepads. After adding the .rules file and rebooting, the Motion Sensors are gone and they don't appear as an extra gamepad/joystick. When you configure your DS4 in Emulationstation, how many gamepads it reports as detected ? Before the .rules file was added, mine reported 2, after it reported only 1.

Take a look at the N64 .cfg file you pasted and pay attention in each of the [Input-SDL-ControlX] sections, to the device = <X> line. Each section assigns a player to gamepad. The device = <X> instructs the emulator to look for the device numbered <X> (numbering starts from 0).
In your file, I see that Wireless Controller Motion Sensors appears in the list, but it shouldn't, since it's not a real gamepad, so the configuration file has been generated when the motion sensors where available.
I'd suggest to rename this .cfg file, then re-install the Mupen64-plus emulator (so the cfg file gets generated again) and then re-configure your DS4 controller. Check the file and see if the controller is correctly registered - i.e. without the Motion Sensors - and how many controllers are registered - i.e. how many [Input-SDL-ControlX] sections are saved.

Try a N64 game and see if both controllers work. Unfortunately I don't have 2 DS4, just one, so I can't test it myself.

MisterMints

@mitu said in Controller config - no longer working:

OK, so I connected a DS4 and - as expected - the systems sees both the Motion Sensors and the Wireless Controller as gamepads. After adding the .rules file and rebooting, the Motion Sensors are gone and they don't appear as an extra gamepad/joystick. When you configure your DS4 in Emulationstation, how many gamepads it reports as detected ? Before the .rules file was added, mine reported 2, after it reported only 1.

Take a look at the N64 .cfg file you pasted and pay attention in each of the [Input-SDL-ControlX] sections, to the device = <X> line. Each section assigns a player to gamepad. The device = <X> instructs the emulator to look for the device numbered <X> (numbering starts from 0).
In your file, I see that Wireless Controller Motion Sensors appears in the list, but it shouldn't, since it's not a real gamepad, so the configuration file has been generated when the motion sensors where available.
I'd suggest to rename this .cfg file, then re-install the Mupen64-plus emulator (so the cfg file gets generated again) and then re-configure your DS4 controller. Check the file and see if the controller is correctly registered - i.e. without the Motion Sensors - and how many controllers are registered - i.e. how many [Input-SDL-ControlX] sections are saved.

Try a N64 game and see if both controllers work. Unfortunately I don't have 2 DS4, just one, so I can't test it myself.

I have a theory then....

I'm sure when I configured the first DS4 it said there were 3 pads connected. 1 being the SNES I used to navigate the menus and the other being my MegaPi case.

I may need to clear all the config files and reinstall the emulator as you've said, but take the Pi out of the case (or at least disconnect the USBs) and start again.

Will try later and report back

MisterMints

Hi @mitu

I think its (almost) solved now!! Thank you for help!

I disconnected everything, except my keyboard, uninstalled mupen64, disconnected and deleted all Bluetooth devices and controller configs and then started again.

I though I should also redo the ignore DS3/DS4 rule, so followed the steps to complete that, and this is where I noticed a (probable) major flaw. My file contained the following:

SUBSYSTEM=="input", ATTRS{name}=="*Motion Sensors", RUN+=="/bin/rm %E{DEVNAME}"

When it actually should've contained this:

SUBSYSTEM=="input", ATTRS{name}=="*Motion Sensors", RUN+="/bin/rm %E{DEVNAME}"

Notice the extra = after RUN+? Looks like that could be what made it not work.

Anyway, removed the extra = and saved the file, rebooted and remapped my DS4s, configured them and fired up Mario Kart 64 and it worked.

Couple of issues remain though! mupen64 still does not respond to any HotKey+ combinations other than Select+Start but I can probably live with that.

When I start the system up it now always complains that no gamepad is connected and asks me to configure one. As soon as I turn a DS4 on and tap a button this goes away, but it is slightly irritating when it just used to sit at the main menu until I connected something.

All inconveniences rather than show stoppers, but if there is any way to prevent the config dialog opening each start up then I'm happy to hear all about it!

Thanks again

mitu

@MisterMints said in Controller config - no longer working:

When I start the system up it now always complains that no gamepad is connected and asks me to configure one. As soon as I turn a DS4 on and tap a button this goes away, but it is slightly irritating when it just used to sit at the main menu until I connected something.

That's the default behavior. I remember seeing somewhere a workaround - configuring a keyboard as a gamepad in the system once, then when ES boots it doesn't ask for a controller to be selected.

Glad you got it working out. You can probably make Start + Select working again - how are you 'skipping' the Hotkey selection in the input configuration dialog ? Are you using the D-pad to skip over, or long-press another button ?

MisterMints

@mitu said in Controller config - no longer working:

@MisterMints said in Controller config - no longer working:

When I start the system up it now always complains that no gamepad is connected and asks me to configure one. As soon as I turn a DS4 on and tap a button this goes away, but it is slightly irritating when it just used to sit at the main menu until I connected something.

That's the default behavior. I remember seeing somewhere a workaround - configuring a keyboard as a gamepad in the system once, then when ES boots it doesn't ask for a controller to be selected.

Glad you got it working out. You can probably make Start + Select working again - how are you 'skipping' the Hotkey selection in the input configuration dialog ? Are you using the D-pad to skip over, or long-press another button ?

@mitu Long pressing down on the D-pad, it then says not defined, I hit OK, then a pop up comes up about No Hotkey enabled - set up the default (or whatever the wording is) and I hit Yes/OK again

MisterMints

@mitu Is it expected that the DS3/DS4 rules file would disable the analogue sticks in PS1 games?

Admittedly I've been focusing on getting the 2 controllers working with N64, but I'm almost certain that Tony Hawk's 2 and Spyro were previously playable with the left joystick, but now only respond to the D-pad.

Is there a way to re-enable the joysticks on PS1 games?

mitu

@MisterMints said in Controller config - no longer working:

Is it expected that the DS3/DS4 rules file would disable the analogue sticks in PS1 games?

No. Check if you have enabled the analog controls in the libretro core options as explained here.

MisterMints

@mitu said in Controller config - no longer working:

@MisterMints said in Controller config - no longer working:

Is it expected that the DS3/DS4 rules file would disable the analogue sticks in PS1 games?

No. Check if you have enabled the analog controls in the libretro core options as explained here.

Got it. Cheers.

MisterMints

~~Just when I thought my issues were fixed....!!

Trying to set up version 2 of this Raspberry Pi - everything is the same as the one discussed above, image from v1 copied and then written to a second SD card and inserted into a second Pi 3B+

As I start it up I'm getting the usual "no gamepad detected" which is fine, I'll live with it, but on v2 only, when I try to map a pad (in this case a second Mega Drive replica, and a brand new out of the box second Mega Drive replica) I cannot map any buttons other than Up, Down, Left, Right, Start and Select.

When I get to button A, I have no response whatever. I thought it might be a faulty controller, but as I've said, also tried it with a one I know works on the original system and get the same issue.

Try rewriting the SD card? Anyway to skip button mapping completely? Something else to try?~~

Ignore. Got it working by changing the input mode of the pad from X input to D input