Deathsmiles on lr-mame2015 : Any performance tips?

pjft

@Darksavior Thanks. So is mine. Just checking whether it would have saved that option from previous testing attempts.

AdamBeGood

@roslof Absolutely loving this game! Didn't know about it until you mentioned it. Proper strange, but I'm enjoying it. The setting really affect it, 55 seems about right.

Anyone - feel free to mention any other games this fix helps.

ecto

@AdamBeGood Can the underclock setting be saved now?

AdamBeGood

@ecto Yep, if you install lr-mame2016 again from Source, then the option is there under Quick Menu->Options and it can be saved.

AdamBeGood

Going back to what originally sparked this, me messing about with my latency settings; could someone let me know what the default settings are please?

If I try and set my Configuration to default then RetroArch freezes and I have to turn the Pi off and on.

That is on the assumption that the default Latency settings are what I should have set up, any other variables I would be happy to run with if they work better. However, I'm sure what I've currently got set isn't the optimum config.

roslof

@AdamBeGood I believe these are default (could verify by renaming the retroarch.cfg file and re-running RetroArch to rebuild it... all of it), but I think these are the default settings:

Max swapchain images 3
Hard CPU Sync OFF/Disabled
Frame Delay 0
Audio Latency (ms) 64
Poll Type Behavior Early
Run-Ahead to Reduce Latency OFF/Disabled

I've been running with these values for months. No issues.

Recommendation: If you continue to crash, check overclock settings (comment them out and see if you're stable).

AdamBeGood

@roslof Superb, I'll bring mine back to those values tomorrow then.

Would overclock affect the system crashing when I select to change settings to Default? It crashes every time, I've tried it a handful of times. I have no instability at any other times.

roslof

@AdamBeGood what is your method of changing default settings?

pjft

@roslof and others,

If you would be so kind as to test this over lr-mame, it'd be very much appreciated. I tried to port the code to lr-mame which was mostly similar, though a few tweaks were needed as some public members of some classes in 2016 no longer existed in the latest code:

https://mega.nz/file/UZtH3KaL#3vZNKoR8IMbo4aSdCIaLDPbs3vrXSMLuPktuRKBkr6c

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1arGrZmKZb8TLag20UbKCAQKHt81ZkOgY/view?usp=sharing

Same kind of tests would help - changing the setting, confirming it actually changes it on MAME, and testing other games you run on lr-mame to confirm that nothing actually breaks.

I tested Deathsmiles and it seems to work well.

at 100%, it runs at average speed: 66.54% (135 seconds)
at 42% runs at average speed: 70.95% (146 seconds)

I tested pacman as well and it didn't crash, so that's success for me.

If this gets its tires kicked and nothing breaks, I'll happily submit this upstream.

Many thanks in advance.

roslof

@pjft said in Deathsmiles on lr-mame2015 : Any performance tips?:

If you would be so kind as to test this over lr-mame, it'd be very much appreciated.

Me? Test a new toy? You cray.

First thing: The change works. Properly saves and loads back perfectly. No remarkable side-effects.

Air Combat (aircomb.zip)
Test: Add 4 Credits. Measure on title Screen
Default: Solid 28.45 FPS
CPU 30: Between 28.87 to 29.72 FPS
Minor Improvement. Values hold perfectly after restart

Virtua Fighter (vf.zip)
Test: Attract Demo
Default: ~32 to 34 FPS
CPU 70: ~32 to 34 FPS
No noticeable improvement. Needs a higher CPU or graphics flicker

Pong (pong.zip)
Test: Attract Demo
Default: 47.5 to 47.8 FPS
CPU 30-50: 47.5 to 47.8 FPS
No noticeable improvement.

Might be GPU bound on these (um, for Pong, I have no idea). CPU change didn't have significant/measurable impact.
But it IS working, since underclocking VF too low resulted in a negative experience.

Will try more games later.
Hope this is helpful

AdamBeGood

@roslof Retroarch Menu -> Configuration File -> Reset to Defaults is what I was going with.

dankcushions

@roslof said in Deathsmiles on lr-mame2015 : Any performance tips?:

@AdamBeGood I believe these are default (could verify by renaming the retroarch.cfg file and re-running RetroArch to rebuild it... all of it)

that will give you retroarch defaults for ALL settings, which will break retropie in various ways. we use our own defaults.

if you've messed up your retroarch settings (just don't change latency stuff unless you know exactly what you're doing, IMO), reinstall retroarch via retropie-setup, and it will create a copy of our stock retroarch.cfg as retroarch.cfg.rp-dist in the /opt/retropie/configs/all/ - delete the old retroarch.cfg and rename the rp-dist one to retroarch.cfg. if you instead messed with an individual core's retroarch.cfg, then reinstall that core and do the rename within /opt/retropie/configs/(whatever)/. if you've created core/game overrides, delete them.

you can see what these various latency settings do here: https://github.com/RetroPie/RetroPie-Setup/wiki/Input-Lag - as you can see, the advice is to NOT change them because they cause known problems.

dankcushions

@AdamBeGood said in Deathsmiles on lr-mame2015 : Any performance tips?:

@roslof Retroarch Menu -> Configuration File -> Reset to Defaults is what I was going with.

this will also give you the same issue i mentioned above.

pjft

@roslof Thanks for testing these out, and above all make sure nothing breaks. That's indeed helpful, and I'll submit the change upstream. Mostly worried about it crashing other games, but it doesn't seem to be the case.

Interesting - I hadn't kept up with MAME, I had no idea that Pong was now emulated. I imagine that it's not a really easy one to emulate, as it was more of a physical simulation if I recall correctly.

http://adb.arcadeitalia.net/dettaglio_mame.php?game_name=pong

Reading the "INFO" tab there will provide some interesting backstory.

Thanks for giving these a shot.

AdamBeGood

@dankcushions Fair enough, I will stop tinkering so much I think! I just really wanted to get DeathSmiles working better, and now it does. Mission accomplished.

I completed it yesterday evening! :)

Thanks very much for all the information, I don't think I've done anything severe enough to warrant reinstalling but it is good to know how to go about that for when I do mess it up!

pjft

@AdamBeGood Nice, great to hear! Did it work well end to end with underclocking?

I'd certainly revert the options to the original ones, at least the ones @roslof mentioned. As @dankcushions stated, the options included in RetroPie are kind of adjusted for better performance in our scenarios.

By the way, I just submitted the PR for lr-mame. Thanks for testing it out @roslof .

AdamBeGood

@pjft Yeah, it was playable! Sometimes incredible slowdown, but it is hard to know how much of that is built into the game and how much of it is the Pi.

I've tried Pink Sweets and Ibara today, they are fairly slow but I think I could maybe play them for a while. Muchi Muchi Pork seems acceptable to me also, better than the other two.

I've reverted those options now!

Good work on the lr-mame PR, hope it goes through as quickly. The underclock is a good option to have, it really makes a difference.

Unless something else comes up, Mystical Ninja Starring Goeman on N64 is now my only significant problem game. Not a bad place to be in really.

stevas

Thanks for the suggestion of over voltage to 6, but it's solved nothing for me.

I try to go anything above:

gpu_freq=700
v3d_freq=750
arm_freq=1950

And the game I'm testing (Dreamcast capcom Vs snk) just craps itself after starting a match (reboots itself).

From the numbers I see talked about on here, either I'm just flat out doing something wrong, or I've been extraordinarily unlucky? Or flycast is glitchy as hell?

pjft

@stevas as mentioned, please start a separate thread and provide more details there. Does the game not crash in lower frequencies? If so, then yes, you're out of luck there.

But don't change GPU freq on the pi 4. Remove that and try again. See this: https://www.raspberrypi.org/documentation/configuration/config-txt/overclocking.md

roslof

@stevas I'm thinking now it's either your kernel version or cooling on the Flirc.

Have you upgraded lately?
https://www.raspberrypi.org/documentation/raspbian/updating.md