Drastic NDS Emulator breaks run command emulator configuration prompt in RetroPie4.2

BuZz

@mediamogul Didn't know about that. The beta was done publicly, and nothing was said about restrictions at the time that I can remember. I'm happy to remove it from RetroPie though if it's a problem.

BuZz

I'm going to remove it. The author doesn't want it in retropie - not a problem.

meleu

@BuZz said in Drastic NDS Emulator breaks run command emulator configuration prompt in RetroPie4.2:

The author doesn't want it in retropie

Did he say it publicly or particularly?

mediamogul

@BuZz

Like I said, it's hard to get a read on how he feels about it. If the beta wasn't intended to go wide, you'd think he wouldn't have released it that way.

mediamogul

@BuZz

If you'd like, I can try reaching out to him and see what his thoughts are directly.

BuZz

@mediamogul feel free.

BuZz

@meleu the author said

It still would have been nice if maintainers of a major front end didn't decide to incorporate it prematurely.

Being the first I heard of this, and the fact that the beta wasn't supposed to be public (even though it was made public), I'm happy to just remove it for now - which I have done.

backstander

I didn't realize Exophase was unhappy with it include in RetroPie.

@mediamogul
Yeah, I think it would be good to have someone representing RetroPie to reach out to him.

mediamogul

@backstander

Will do. I'll even wear my Sunday church clothes.

ExarKunIv

well that's a bummer.
it really works great on the Pi. Hope that he can be convinced to let it stay

mediamogul

My post is currently under moderation:

Hello Exophase,

I'm a moderator over at the RetroPie forums and it's recently come to light that the inclusion of DraStic is potentially something that you wish had not happened. It was assumed by the nature of it's release that this might be an acceptable course of action and I can assure you that no ill will was intended. In an effort to respect your wishes and your work, the ability to install DraStic has been removed from the RetroPie-Setup script. Anyone wishing to test the beta as intended can still or course install it manually. I'm sure I speak for the rest of the RetroPie community when I say that we hope you continue your work on the Raspberry Pi and that the inclusion of a more finalized version of DraStic might be possible in the future with your blessing.

Thanks for all your time.

It might take him a while to respond, but it should be posted here when he does.

meleu

@mediamogul I think my english is not so polished but I think that it is worth to mention that drastic was in the "experimental packages", i.e. that section where the users are aware that issues can happen...

mediamogul

@meleu

That's a good point. I'll be sure to mention that as the dialog continues and ask if he's ok with the current beta being there.

Charononus

I've heard some people saying that the manual installation method is gone now. Can anyone confirm that this is true? I was looking for a the link to it on github and not finding it.

meleu

@Charononus the drastic script module was removed from RetroPie-Setup. If you wanna try it on your end, the old script module is here: https://github.com/RetroPie/RetroPie-Setup/blob/c522c722b6753b1908d7f5fa00b4bc1e105e514a/scriptmodules/emulators/drastic.sh

Charononus

@meleu

ok yeah just read through the script and his download is still active. I know some people that thought that the retropie script was initially pulling from git not from drastic-ds, and wanted to set it up manually to comply with his wishes yet still use it.

Charononus

@mediamogul

I just checked the page you linked, did you get any kind of response at all about things? Just curious. I'm highly impressed with his work.

mediamogul

@Charononus

I'm highly impressed with his work.

His work is impressive. I wish DraStic was open source so everyone could get a better look. However, there are a few posts on that forum where he goes into certain details more thoroughly and it's all very interesting. In answer to your question, he has not responded in any way that I'm aware.

steptoe

I've had a quick read through the Drastic forums and this is his response to why paid users of his work were complaining why is it 'free' on the RPI

It's on Raspberry Pi because I released the port for it, as a semi-closed beta. I asked people not to distribute it but since I did link to it publicly somewhere it was basically inevitable. It still would have been nice if maintainers of a major front end didn't decide to incorporate it prematurely. That said, I still plan to release an "official" first version although at this point the lines have been really blurred as to what that even means.

As for why they get to use it for free, I guess I don't have much of an answer for that other than that it's simply up to my discretion and I don't think the RPi ecosystem or community is a good fit for paid apps. This isn't completely without precedent, I released the Pandora version of DraStic (which the RPi one is more similar to than the Android) without charging, and before the Android version.

The answer seems to suggest that it will still be supported as the RPI isn't seen as much of a threat to his work more getting it 'out there' and hoping people will register to offer support for future work

GtBFilms

@steptoe "RPI isn't seen as much of a threat to his work more getting it 'out there' "

Which is exactly what happened with me, I discovered Drastic on RetroPie, and then purchased it for use on the move on my GPD Q9 - perhaps more people will help support it, as it's an awesome piece of work.